I have lunch each Thursday with a group of girlfriends, and they know my husband and I go to the movies almost every Friday night. They have asked me to post reviews to our Yahoo Group's website, and I though I might share it with you also. Keep in mind, this is from a "chick's" point of view.
First of all, let's go over Jackie's (the non-film critic) ratings
system:
5 Lipsticks - Must see, excellent movie which leaves you with
something more than just a couple of hours well spent.
4 Lipsticks - Great flick, enjoyable, maybe even moving; see it if
you want to be up to date around the water cooler.
3 Lipsticks - Good, old-fashioned one for the girls. Nice story,
pretty people, entertaining.
2 Lipsticks - One or two good performances, overall not the best way
to spend time and money.
1 Lipstick - One for the boys only. Probably lots of things
exploding.
0 Lipsticks - No redeeming social value whatsoever. Do not give
these people your money.
Okay, that sounds about right. Now for the disclaimer: I am not a
film critic. I have never taken a film class and know nothing about
camera angles, lighting or any of the other astounding crafts that go
into movie-making. I just go to a lot of movies. This is my opinion
only, and does not represent the musings of anyone other than
myself. I have no financial interest in any entertainment
corporation and I can't believe anyone would be interested in my
opinion. But, being a Democrat, I offer it anyway.
Mamma Mia
3 1/2 Lipsticks (Preferably a fabulous shade of Pink)
This one put a smile on my face from the opening sound track to the
end of the credits, which everyone stayed for just to hear the great
music. If you are an ABBA fan, this is a must see....happy,
energetic and totally unimportant. Pure escapism. Meryl Streep
never looked better and sang pretty well too. The scene with her
using the bed for a trampoline was amazing. They must have CGI'd in
her Russian jump (think Cossacks) because I cannot believe she can do
that at her age. The relationship between ex-girl group lead singer
and aging hippie Streep, whose daughter's wedding precipitates the
reunion of all the characters on an impossibly beautiful Greek
island, and her two best friends and backup singers Christine
Baranski and Julie Walters is what we all wish for as we face the
last half of life. The three men who are possible candidates for
father-of-the-bride (Streep's character has a past) are appropriately
played as mere supporting characters. The only negative is that
Pierce Brosnan really cannot sing, but who cares? Colin Firth does
his goofy middle aged character to perfection, and I can't say enough
about Christine Baranski and Julie Walters. They have long been
favorites of mine and do not disappoint here. I truly enjoyed this
one, and Ted did too, although I know men who would grumble "chick
flick," and go see something being exploded.
-
08/04/08 20:25pm PDT katem
Julie Walters is always great. I love ABBA...so Muriel's Wedding was one of my favorites as well. -
07/28/08 15:47pm PDT Jeneclectic
Most film critics are male so it's nice to see a rating scale from a female POV. -
07/27/08 20:15pm PDT boomer
Ummm, vicarious embarrassment might a bright pink lipstick with dark red lip liner not blended! -
07/27/08 19:11pm PDT allyb
The lipstick meter sounds great! It is definitely a good method when rating chick flicks or girly movies. I have not seen Mamma Mia yet, but I am hoping to see it soon! -
07/27/08 18:26pm PDT kateg
I love the lipstick scale... it's a perfect way to measure the chickometer. I saw this movie last weekend--I think somewhere around 3 lipsticks sounds about right (I'm not an ABBA fan, so obviously, there was a lipstick smudge here, for me). But it was light, fun, and entertaining...especially as you point out to see Pierce Brosnan try to sing. What's the shade of lipstick for "vicarious embarrassment"?


Love the lipstick scale : ) Saw Mamma Mia with my Mom; were both dancing along with the music; love Meryl Streep!